Sports journalist Erin Riley trolled after commenting on AFL Grand Final

A long way to go: Adam Goodes (right) was racially abused during the grand final.

A long way to go: Adam Goodes (right) was racially abused during the grand final. Photo: Quinn Rooney

No matter how much experience you have with online abuse and trolling, it still has the power to shock you with both the ferocity of its hatred and the overwhelmingly imbalanced nature of its anger. Sometimes the only thing you can do is stand there open mouthed and marvel once again at the fact people think we’re living in a post-feminist era.

So it was that I reacted to news that sports journalist Erin Riley was enduring relentless online hostility following the publication of a weekend article in which she challenged the AFL to take a bolder stand on the racism, sexism and homophobia exhibited by some of its fanbase. Riley, whose Honours thesis looked at the history of Australian Rules football in NSW before 1982 and who has been writing professionally about sport for almost a decade, wrote succinctly and passionately about the need for better action on bigotry within the AFL culture. While attending the Grand Final on Saturday, Riley - a long-time Swans supporter - was angered by the actions of some Hawthorn supporters seated near her. She writes:

A screen shot of the Twitter abuse hurled at Erin Riley.

A screen shot of the Twitter abuse hurled at Erin Riley.

“They shouted that Adam Goodes was racist. They referred to Sydney players only by female pronouns – implying, of course, that being female is to be laughable and weak. And when the Hawks led by a large margin in the last quarter, they started chanting, "Sydney take it up the a---, doodah, doodah".”

Advertisement

Riley complained to a security guard, only to be told that there was nothing he could do because “all the fans do it”. She says that another complainant was met with the same reaction.

As far as revelations go, none of this is particularly surprising. The shortfalls of a society still wrestling with its own innate sexism means that any large congregation of people (particularly those meeting in an arena pumping with competition and testosterone) will boast a minority of people determined to either ruin it for everyone else or reduce it to the lowest common denominator.

Writer Erin Riley was harrassed by online trolls after her AFL Grand Final comment piece was published on SMH.

Writer Erin Riley was harrassed by online trolls after her AFL Grand Final comment piece was published on SMH. Photo: Facebook

That a handful of people - Hawks supporters or otherwise - thought it would be hilarious to yell out racist, sexist and homophobic epithets in their drunken stupor doesn’t surprise me.

But what does still manage to surprise me is the utter hostility with which some people will treat others when they speak out against such behaviour. For her efforts, Riley has been called a ‘retard’, a ‘s--t person’ who ‘deserves all the crap [she’s] been given’, a ‘disgraceful sexist man-hater’ (because it wouldn’t be trolling if it didn’t follow all the rules of the cliche book), a liar and, bizarrely, a racist.

She’s been told to kill herself, while others have pointed to her as proof that ‘women are dumb c--ts who don’t know s--t about footy’. Someone even made a big show of alerting Tinder, inviting a volunteer to ‘take one for the team’ and ‘get Riley a root’. Because the obvious solution to stop women from being upset about misogyny and juvenile sexism is just to get a good dick up them. Honestly, you could power several small nations for decades with the force of that kind of massively unwarranted male ego.

The internet shorthand of Lewis’ Law dictates that feminism will be justified by the comments on any article about feminism, and it’s true in Riley’s case. Not one but two threads devoted to humiliating and ridiculing her were started on Big Footy, with commenters assessing her as all manner of things ranging from ‘mentally unstable’ to overly sensitive. (And can we just enjoy for a moment the predictability of people posting excessively sensitive vitriol about how insulted they are because other overly sensitive people are too easily insulted? The irony is so crisp it could cut glass.)

One poster linked to her Twitter feed (a classic online dog whistle often employed by the likes of Andrew Bolt that encourages feverish bullies to rush forth and tear strips off) and mused, ‘61,000 tweets? Someone is a bit full of their own importance.’ Because, I don’t know, being a regular user of the seventh most popular website in the world means you think you’re hot s--t or something.

If the AFL and its associated fan-based culture doesn’t have a problem with women and other minorities, why is still so difficult to speak openly about some of its seedier aspects without being threatened with vile abuse and ridicule? What does it say about the values of a culture when a large part of this retaliation involves fans demanding complainants to ‘suck it up Princess!’ and accept that ‘subversive humour’ is part of a long and glorious tradition of AFL larrikinism?

The days of ongoing bigotry and casual misogyny on the field and in the stands of one of Australia’s most loved sporting monoliths being excused as just a bit of rowdy fun are over. As Riley says, football isn’t just a game for white men any more and its community culture should reflect that. If the AFL is really serious about breeding inclusivity, it needs to reflect that by adopting a zero tolerance policy to all forms of abuse. As General-Lietenant David Morrison famously said of the ADF, ‘The standard you walk past is the standard you accept.’ 

In her 2013 book ‘Night Games’, an exploration of sex, power and sport, journalist Anna Krien addresses some of the conflicting feelings which rose for her throughout the research process. She writes, “The last thing I wanted was to be a killjoy - and yet I kept recalling the words of the Australian sociologist Lois Bryson. She once wrote that feminists who ignore sport do so at their own peril, and I couldn’t shake the feeling that this was all the more true when it came to footy.”

It may be true that the AFL has made great strides in changing its culture on the ground. But judging from the obnoxious and brutal response to Riley’s weekend piece, some of the attitudes of its fans still have a long way to go. It’s time for the AFL to stop passing the ball to someone else, and start doing something.

 

79 comments

  • Watching THE football game is so much fun. Watching sexist fans much less so. Come on guys, grow up and enjoy the game.

    Commenter
    Martyn Tilse
    Location
    Brisbane
    Date and time
    September 30, 2014, 5:55AM
    • I couldn't agree more. I love footy and as a Hawks supporter I was thrilled on Saturday but this kind of awful behaviour from the crowd is shameful and embarrassing. There is no excuse and sports writers should be pointing it out. We have a long way to go.

      Commenter
      JMK
      Date and time
      September 30, 2014, 12:37PM
    • Yep, likewise with both of you. In some ways, it seems to be getting worse. The hostility of home crowds (my own included) seems to have escalated over the last year or two. I was shocked several years ago to hear the venom from the crowds in Adelaide, and was told it was seen as 'supporting your team'. Bollocks, supporting your team has nothing to do with jeering and ridiculing players from the other side who are simply playing the game, and having a shot at goal.

      That now seems to have extended to most Melbourne clubs, who in the past, could point to you-know-who as the only team whose die-hard fans were considered aggressive and abusive.

      To that 'negative' volume, we have added not just abuse, but foul swearing, sexist, racist, homophobic abuse that sometimes gets lost in the overall loud noise.

      It wasn't just Hawthorn - who was the Sydney fan leaning over the fence shouting abusive comments to the Hawthorn player in the last quarter? Great example for kids.

      Commenter
      cuts both ways
      Location
      Cats fan
      Date and time
      September 30, 2014, 1:48PM
    • I agree with Erin and unfortunately, have been subject to the same type of offensive language and behaviour when at the football.

      I live and breathe football and love to watch my team play, but it is becoming less and less enjoyable having to put up with supporters who yell abuse at players and also do not treat fellow supporters with respect.

      Commenter
      Louram
      Date and time
      September 30, 2014, 2:00PM
  • After living overseas I took my young family to the GF parade for the first time. I was ashamed to see banners saying things like F--- off swans. This isn't the game and supporters I remember from my childhood.

    Commenter
    Country Vic
    Date and time
    September 30, 2014, 5:55AM
    • Sadly, that *is* the game I remember from my youth... which would be why no-one in my family (male or female) watches or is interested in footy :(

      Commenter
      andilee
      Location
      Melbourne
      Date and time
      September 30, 2014, 11:27AM
  • AFL is a secret society to numb the minds of the masses in victoria. Surprisingly it does it to both sexes when you compae it to league and football I would have to say there is a lot more passionate women follow afl then any other code.

    Still a silly game created for eight year olds.

    Commenter
    kbf
    Date and time
    September 30, 2014, 9:56AM
    • Not everything in life has to be complicated to be enjoyable. Swimming at the beach is something 8 year olds can do also yet is enjoyable for all ages.

      Commenter
      Bob
      Location
      Strathfield
      Date and time
      September 30, 2014, 12:00PM
    • Bob if you make watching eight years a sport you will get arrested.

      Commenter
      kbf
      Date and time
      September 30, 2014, 1:09PM
  • If only courage and some modicum of intelligence was a pre requisite to be able to reproduce, the problem of these pathetic wastes of oxygen would be solved...

    Commenter
    Paul
    Location
    Kew
    Date and time
    September 30, 2014, 10:08AM

    More comments

    Comments are now closed